Composite Pipe Repair
Gray E Fowler
gfowler at raytheon.com
Wed Sep 24 06:14:35 AKDT 2003
I did not mean to leave everyone hanging, but I had to go...more on this
subject. Concerning composite built pipes of any brand. First the main
problem with the pipes made from epoxy is not the fact that the resin
matrix is epoxy, but more from the epoxy that was chosen. Most of the
pipes that I have seen are made by taking commercially available carbon
fiber braid and conforming it down to a male mandrel. This braid is dry
and needs to be wetted out with epoxy. Since most of our Pattern equipment
is produced by innovative small business guys, working out of their garage
or something, most of the epoxies that could survive are not feasible to
use in this method of producing the pipe. The choice is limited by two
factors, one-the need for the resin to be liquid at room temperature, Two-
the need for the resin to "set" at room temperature, then maybe postcure
after room temp gel. These two factors force the manufacturer to use an
epoxy resin similar to the adhesive I mentioned earlier, Hysol 9394,
supposedly a 350F system. Technically speaking, this is and aromatic
amine cured epoxy. The temperature resistance of the epoxy comes from the
use of the aromatic amine. Two problems that relate to aromatic
amine....they are soilds at room temperature and they really need elevated
temperaures to cure-hence violating the fab needs stated earlier. So
Hysol 9394, and other "liquid" aromatic amines usualy have copius amounts
of regular primary amine, which are liquid and cure easily at room
temperature---and have low temp resistance.
So at 350F these epoxy systems work, albeit at dramtically reduced
strength (75% reduction), and that is one reason for crushed inlets. Even
at about 400F the epoxy does not burn but has little to no strength. Along
comes the hot day and slightly lean run, the exhaust temp goes up and
bye-bye inlet tube. Long aluminum headers and rich runs protect the inlet
from that temperature. As you can see these type of epoxy systems are
absolutely borderline effective. That is why half of you guys say never
had a problem and the other half burn up your inlet tube.
Concerning the post directing people to sources of 600F epoxy.....Sorry no
such thing- period. Look closely at the web site info. No structural data,
because these are potting compounds, AND guess what...they need high
temperatures to cure. As a potting compound these materials can take short
duration spikes up to 600F and not burn up, but the will be soft rubbery
gels with zero strength, which works for those applications because it is
a potting compound only.
The only way to get high temp properties from an epoxy is use an epoxy
that cures at high temp, but this has problems of its own. Applying-Using
an aromatic amine cured epoxy at 250F is just like using a liquid epoxy at
room temperature......only the humanoid operator has cooling problems at
this condition so this is not feasible (without an asbestos suit).
Attempts to wet out braids with viscous epoxy/A-amine goo with a heat gun
will work, but as the temperaure is raised to cure at 350F, all the
trapped air expands creating voids in the laminate and leaks in the
pipe....bad-bad. Curing under a vacuum enhances the expansion of trapped
air BUT if you can get it all out the no pinhole leaks.....but there is no
way to really do this perfect everytime.
Epoxy of any type WILL NOT absorb oil. But pinhole leaks, microcracks and
sanded outter surfaces exposing the fiber will. Pinholes come from the
process problems mentioned above, microcracks come from stress at
temperature, and sanding the outside of the pipe is a cosmetic REQUIREMENT
from all you totally anal retentive pattern types that gotta have a "Good
Lookin" pipe......one word here-function! Hats off to Bolly! they use a
high temp Bismaleimide resin (I think) AND they do not sand the outside of
the pipe. Granted, it looks like something that shoulda gotten flushed,
but it does not burn out, and it does not absorb oil. It is also for this
reason heavier by a couple of ozs.
The answer.....do it the way the B-2 was done.....epoxy-aromatic amine (or
bismaleimide or cyanate ester) prepreg cured in an autoclave.....Now can
you afford this? Perhaps. To avoid blatant advertising I will stop here.
Anyone interested please email me offline at Aeroslave at comcast.net.
Gray Fowler
Principal Chemical Engineer
Composites Engineering
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.f3a.us/pipermail/nsrca-discussion/attachments/20030924/14acbbf9/attachment.html
More information about the NSRCA-discussion
mailing list