Judging Landing & takoffs. (was Re: Spoilers for Pattern Planes?????)

[Del Rykert]

I agree here and I was taught that takeoffs are centered but landings are to use the 30m zone. Is that not that the intended interpretation.
 
     Del K. Rykert
     AMA - 8928 
     NSRCA - 473
     Kb2joi - General 


  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: davel322 at comcast.net 
  To: discussion at nsrca.org 
  Sent: Tuesday, November 11, 2003 3:41 PM
  Subject: Landing (was Re: Re: Spoilers for Pattern Planes?????)


  Respectfully, I must disagree.

  If the rules aren't being followed, they should not be eliminated.

  Barrel rolls and "twinkle" rolls pretending to be snap rolls routinely get 
  scored and should be zeroed.  Should we stop judging snaps?

  Flopped stall turns (more than 150 degrees off in roll axis) routinely are not 
  zeroed.  Should we stop judging stall turns?

  Judging is not an easy task, and there will always be room for improvement.  
  Where the rules are gray (no matter how clear they seemed when originally 
  authored) and interpreted in various ways, there is room to clarify the rules.  
  When the rules are clear and ignored, they need to be politely enforced.

  So far as landing - we have a system for scoring centering on maneuvers and I 
  personally don't think we need something different for landing - it is just an 
  additional rule that adds needless complexity (but I will follow it as long as 
  it is there).  Besides, at many fields, the landing zone is never marked, or 
  because of field layout, the landing zone is not used (in which case landing in 
  the zone or centering of the landing would not be part of the judging criteria).

  Dave Lockhart
  DaveL322 at comcast.net
  > Wayne:
  > 
  > Exactly the point.  If we can't follow the rules to judge it properly, maybe
  > it's time to quit judging it.  After all, this maneuver has not changed
  > much, even from the early days of pattern  <VBG>  So, if we STILL can't
  > judge it, let's try something else....
  > 
  > I see this problem at most all of the contests every year, including the
  > NATS.  I judge Masters class, and find that many of the FAI judges sitting
  > with me don't know the rules to judge it.
  > 
  > 
  > Tony Stillman
  > Radio South
  > 3702 N. Pace Blvd.
  > Pensacola, FL 32505
  > 1-800-962-7802
  > www.radiosouthrc.com
  > ----- Original Message ----- 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.f3a.us/pipermail/nsrca-discussion/attachments/20031111/b69cadd3/attachment.html