WC Judge

[tony at radiosouthrc.com]

Earl:

Well spoken.  All on the list, INCLUDING BOB NOLL would have don't a great job.  However, Don earned it with the best score and as you said, the organizers could pick anyone on the list.  They choose based on PERFORMANCE, not POLITICS.    

Tony Stillman
Radio South
3702 N. Pace Blvd.
Pensacola, FL 32505
1-800-962-7802
www.radiosouthrc.com
  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Earl Haury 
  To: Discussion List, NSRCA 
  Sent: Monday, December 13, 2004 10:09 AM
  Subject: WC Judge


  CONGRATULATIONS DON!

  For those of you who may not know - Don earned this honor through a great deal of hard work, not politics. I originally ask Don to serve on the NSRCA Judges Committee, as I recognized him as dedicated to the rules, sincere in understanding the details, and willing to work for continued excellence. Since that time he has exceeded expectations. He takes of his time to conduct judge cert classes, including at the Nats when he could be practicing. My only regret is that I fly in front of him at most contests that I attend and nothing get by him - he's too darn accurate.

  For the nay-sayers. Yes, Don kept in touch with the folks that developed the judges rating system and offered suggestions for making it equitable. Gee - don't we all want a fair system? Isn't it reasonable that the person with the most dedication to judging would do well, even if they are aware of the system? Understand also that, while representing one's country as a WC Judge is an honor - it's not easy and it's not free. The preparation is intense and the work load is similar to judging all rounds at a Nats. Yes - the WC organizers provide some travel expenses, housing (2 judges per room), and a per diem, but it doesn't cover actual expenses. As I recall, when I judged the WC in 1999 the NSRCA did pay me $30/day also, the same as for the Nats. Those were the only funds provided by NSRCA - the rest came from the host (AMA in my case.)

  Also - the French organizers for the 2005 WC requested résumé's from the folks on the official FAI Judges list, which was put in place earlier (late 2003 or early 2004) and is the official list for 2004 - 2005. That list includes me, Bob Noll, Don, Matt Kebabjian, and Roy Speights. This list precedes the NSRCA rankings update after the 2004 Nats. The organizers reviewed the résumé's and the current NSRCA data and made their choice. Anyone on the list is capable of doing an excellent job, but Don currently has the best performance records and the organizers recognized this. This illustrates respect for the NSRCA worldwide and is good for USA pattern.

  So - again - congratulations to Don.

  Earl Haury
  NSRCA 191
  USA WC Judge 1999

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.f3a.us/pipermail/nsrca-discussion/attachments/20041213/07df7954/attachment.html